2025 NFL Draft: Eight Riskiest Prospects

The Allure of Potential vs. Proven Talent

The NFL Draft is a captivating blend of hope and uncertainty. Each year, teams are tempted by the siren song of "potential," often prioritizing dazzling athleticism over proven on-field performance. This can lead to brilliant successes, like Micah Parsons, who defied his limited college sack numbers to become a dominant force in the NFL. But for every Parsons, there are countless others who fail to reach their perceived potential.

The 2025 NFL Draft appears particularly perilous, especially at the quarterback position. This year's crop of prospects features several high-risk, high-reward players who could either lead a franchise to glory or send a general manager packing. Here are eight prospects to watch with a mixture of excitement and trepidation.

8. Shedeur Sanders, QB, Colorado

Shedeur Sanders possesses the arm talent and pro-style experience to excel in the NFL. He's incredibly accurate and can make throws on the move. However, concerns linger about his leadership style and dedication to winning. Reports of entitlement and a flashy persona raise questions about his fit within a team dynamic.

Furthermore, Sanders' tendency to hold onto the ball too long and scramble into sacks needs addressing. While some sacks are due to offensive line deficiencies, his 95 sacks taken over the last two seasons signal a potential issue.

7. Will Johnson, CB, Michigan

When healthy, Will Johnson is a game-changing cornerback with All-Big Ten accolades and a knack for interceptions. But "when healthy" is the operative phrase. Johnson's injury history, including a turf toe injury that sidelined him for most of 2024 and a recent hamstring issue, is a major red flag.

Beyond injuries, Johnson's gambling tendencies in coverage and inconsistent physicality despite his size present significant concerns. The NFL’s intricate passing attacks will undoubtedly test his weaknesses.

6. Cam Ward, QB, Miami

Cam Ward's meteoric rise from Incarnate Word to Miami is an inspiring story. He's a dynamic playmaker with a lightning-quick release and impressive improvisational skills. However, his decision to opt out of Miami's bowl game after the first half raises serious questions about his leadership and commitment to his teammates.

Ward's reliance on improvisation, while exciting, could be a double-edged sword in the NFL. His "parking lot" style may lead to spectacular highlights, but also costly turnovers.

5. Tetairoa McMillan, WR, Arizona

With a prototypical frame and an impressive touchdown total, Tetairoa McMillan looks the part of a dominant NFL receiver. He possesses smooth route running and an ability to shield defenders from the ball. However, his production has been inconsistent, with half of his 2024 touchdowns coming in a single game against a weak opponent.

McMillan's surprising lack of suddenness and a tendency to drop passes also raise concerns. He’s a finesse receiver in a big man's body, a profile that has led to several first-round busts in the past.

4. Nick Emmanwori, S, South Carolina

Nick Emmanwori’s Combine performance was the stuff of legend. His elite athleticism suggests a future star. While he’s shown flashes of that potential on the field, his inconsistent physicality and average instincts in coverage raise concerns.

Emmanwori isn’t the surefire star his workout numbers suggest, but he possesses the raw tools to become one with proper coaching and development.

3. Cameron Skattebo, RB, Arizona State

Cameron Skattebo is a throwback running back who thrives on contact. He’s a powerful runner who rarely goes down on first contact. However, concerns exist about his lateral agility and ability to evade defenders in the open field. His straight-line running style makes him a boom-or-bust prospect, reminiscent of former bust Trent Richardson.

2. Shemar Stewart, DL, Texas A&M

Shemar Stewart's Combine performance drew comparisons to Myles Garrett. But while their athletic profiles are similar, their production in college couldn’t be more different. Stewart’s paltry 4.5 sacks over three seasons is a glaring red flag.

While Stewart’s pressure numbers suggest untapped potential, he needs to translate that potential into consistent on-field production to justify a first-round selection.

1. Jalen Milroe, QB, Alabama

Jalen Milroe’s exceptional athleticism and dual-threat ability are enticing in today's NFL. However, his subpar accuracy and anticipation are major concerns. These issues, if not addressed, will limit his effectiveness as a passer at the next level.

Milroe’s physical gifts and leadership traits make him an intriguing prospect worth a gamble. However, the team that drafts him must be patient and willing to develop his passing skills.